
Yet rather than building the tribute around the younger generation of neotraditional artists directly inspired by Brooks & Dunn, the CMAs chose to turn the celebration into a hard rock spectacle. The result became one of the most awkward “fart and fall down” moments in country music history. Even Brooks & Dunn appeared disconnected from the performance, judging by their expressions throughout the segment.
Ronnie Dunn made his feelings apparent when he took the stage to accept the award. He revealed that his wife had asked, “Where was the steel guitar in that?” Dunn also shared, “Vince [Gill] is sitting over there saying, ‘That ain’t country’.”
The tribute opened with Halestorm delivering a full metal rendition of “Boot Scootin’ Boogie.” Marcus King provided perhaps the night’s strongest moment, turning “Rock My World (Little Country Girl)” into a Southern rock performance complete with an impressive guitar solo. Brothers Osborne, whose sound has leaned heavily toward rock in recent years, followed with “Hard Workin’ Man,” before Hardy took on “Hillbilly Deluxe” with a performance marked by his signature howling.
Then, as if the segment had not already strayed far enough from its roots, the CMAs brought out Luke Bryan to perform “Play Something Country.”
By the time it ended, the high-energy tribute had become a chaotic spectacle and a major missed opportunity to celebrate the ’90s country era that continues to influence both artists and fans today. That was the legacy Brooks & Dunn were supposed to represent. It was also the spirit behind the standing ovation Sammy Kershaw received earlier in the ceremony.

This is not to dismiss the artists who were invited to take part. Each brought their own strengths to the stage, particularly Halestorm and frontwoman Lzzy Hale, who delivered exactly the kind of rock performance they are known for. As the saying goes, you order a tiger, you’re going to get a tiger. The problem was that a hard rock tribute was never what the occasion called for.
The roots of the problem may lie in Brooks & Dunn’s tribute album series, Reboot (2019) and Reboot II (2024). The idea appears to have been to take the rock-oriented covers from both records and combine them into one sprawling segment, much like a Dagwood sandwich. Those tracks were among the least successful moments on the albums, and bringing them together produced what may have been one of the weakest tributes in CMA Awards history.

Hopefully, the CMAs take this as a lesson for future ceremonies. The lineup already included non-country acts such as Taylor Swift and Mumford & Sons, so there was no need to turn the Brooks & Dunn tribute into a rock showcase. Country fans were there to celebrate the duo’s legacy, while rock fans were unlikely to tune in just to hear Halestorm perform a country song. Brooks & Dunn deserved a tribute that honored their place in country music, not a hard rock spectacle.